Strong Messages Abound In This Interesting Story
WHAT IT’S ABOUT
Life in prison is often a nightmare, but Joe Moore believes he is just where God intends him to be. Twenty-five years ago, while high on meth, he makes one terrible mistake after another, culminating in the brutal murder of a young, influential couple. Today, Joe is a radically different person, thriving in his role as a ministry leader and role model to his fellow inmates.
After being fired from two previous law firms, young lawyer Ryan Clark and his wife, Paige, have settled into a small North Carolina town. Hired by a distant relative, Ryan is committed to connecting with the right clients and handling the mundane tasks while his cousin Tom takes on the high-profile cases.
But when critical health issues land Tom in the hospital, Ryan is forced to take the helm at the law firm–just in time for the town’s biggest case in history to be reopened. Joe Moore’s niece has been doing some digging and, convinced that her incarcerated uncle is innocent, insists that Ryan relaunch the investigation immediately.
After Ryan meets with Joe, both men receive threats that put their own lives–as well as the lives of those around them–in danger. It appears that together they’ve pulled back a dark curtain that hides a deeper evil than anyone in town suspects exists. Now they must determine if continuing with the case is worth the risk–and if the cost of proving one man’s innocence is too great when the lives of so many others would be placed in mortal danger.
Dive into a world where faith meets the law in this heart-pounding legal drama that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Pick up Guilty Until Innocent and find out if the cost of justice is worth risking everything. You won’t want miss out on this thrilling story of grace, redemption, and the relentless pursuit of truth.
- Publisher Thomas Nelson
- February 4, 2025
- Paperback 464 pages

Guilty Until Innocent is a novel that weaves themes of redemption, forgiveness, and making the best of a situation into a compelling narrative. This book fits squarely within the Christian fiction genre, so readers who enjoy stories with a spiritual undertone will find it particularly engaging. However, those less inclined towards Christian fiction should be aware of its focus.
A Journey of Redemption
The story centers around Joe Moore, a man whose life has been a tumultuous journey from darkness to light. Twenty-five years ago, Joe was a different person—a man lost in the throes of addiction, making catastrophic decisions that led to the tragic murder of a young and influential couple. The novel takes readers through Joe’s transformation as he serves his time in prison, evolving into a ministry leader and a beacon of hope for his fellow inmates. This transformation is a testament to the power of faith and the possibility of redemption, no matter the past.
Character Depth and Development
The characters in Guilty Until Innocent are well-developed and bring depth to the story. Joe Moore, in particular, is a multifaceted character whose journey from prison is both inspiring and thought-provoking. His interactions with other inmates and his role as a ministry leader highlight the themes of forgiveness and personal growth.
Legal Themes on the Back Burner
As someone who enjoys books with a legal theme, I approached this novel with eager anticipation. While the legal elements are present, they play a secondary role to the character-driven narrative. The focus remains on the personal and spiritual journeys of the characters, which are skillfully crafted and engaging.
Final Thoughts
Guilty Until Innocent will resonate with fans of Christian fiction and those who appreciate stories of personal transformation. It reminds readers that no matter their past mistakes, there is always a path to redemption and a chance to make a positive impact on the world. The novel’s exploration of these themes, combined with its intriguing characters, makes it a worthwhile read for those open to its spiritual message.
My thanks to Thomas Nelson for a gifted book. I was under no obligation to post a review.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Robert Whitlow is a best-selling author of legal novels and winner of the prestigious Christy Award for Contemporary Fiction.
A practicing attorney, Whitlow and his wife, Kathy, have four children. They make their home in Charlotte, North Carolina.

I may earn a small commission if you purchase through the links in this post. This helps support Pick a Good Book and allows us to continue bringing you great content.